Ruhl Forensic Leader in Forensic Technology

Publications

Technical Papers


SAE 2010-01-0046
Observed Errors in Distance Estimation

Mark Strauss and James Carnahan

In order to evaluate the variation in distance estimation accuracy, a survey was conducted during which 123 subjects estimated distances to static objects in a roadway setting. The subjects (including many police officers) tended to underestimate distances to objects that were from 21 to 383 feet away; the average estimation error was – 8.6% while the median error was – 22%. The variation in performance among individuals was extremely large, with extreme errors ranging from – 96% to + 811%. The distribution of error did not conform to a Gaussian (normal) distribution because of the skew of the observed error distribution towards large positive errors. Box plots were used to identify nine “outlier” respondents who produced a total of 15 error estimates which were extraordinary in their difference from the rest of the data. Tests for independence indicated that the likelihood of an error estimate being an outlier was not influenced by gender, age, or whether the subject was a police officer. When males were compared to females, both were found to have median estimation errors that were negative, corresponding to under-estimation. When nonparametric statistical methods were used to compare the median distance estimation errors, females’ under-estimation errors were found to be larger (more negative) in a statistically significant way. In this survey, in general, the most accurate estimates were given by older males at short distances.

When asked to estimate the length of an average car, there were seven outliers. There was no statistically significant relationship between the likelihood of being an outlier and the subjects' gender, age, or whether they were a police officer. The median under-estimation errors for car length exhibited by females and younger respondents were larger, and were statistically significant.

For a complete copy of this paper, contact:

Society of Automotive Engineers
400 Commonwealth Drive
Warrendale, PA 15096-0001
(724)776-4841 (Phone)
(724)776-5760 (Fax)


Technical Papers

SAE 2013-01-0785
The Accuracy of Pedestrians in Estimating the Speed of a Moving Vehicle

SAE 2010-01-0046
Observed Errors in Distance Estimation

SAE 2007-01-0758
The Experimental Study of the Air Flow Produced by Road Vehicles and its Potential Destabilizing Effect on Nearby Pedestrians

SAE 2006-01-3557
Usable Models for Free and Forced Cooling of Commercial Vehicle Drum Brakes

SAE 2006-01-3556
Comparison of Established Heavy Brake Heating / Cooling Models with HVE Brake Designer in a Real Mountain Accident

RF2005-01
Commercial Vehicle Onboard Electronics - Global Positioning Systems, Engine Control Modules and Safety Systems and Devices

IMECE2004-59566
Analysis of a Common Cause Hypothesis in a Forensic Product Defect Analysis

SAE 2004-01-2717
Safety Concerns in Automatic Control of Heavy-Duty Articulated Vehicles

SAE 2003-01-3393
Numerical Methods for Evaluating ECM Data in Accident Reconstruction and Vehicle Dynamics

SAE 2003-01-3363
Development of a Dynamic Model of an Air-ride Seat for On-highway Trucks

SAE 2003-01-3419
Simulation of Intelligent Convoy with Autonomous Articulated Commercial Vehicles

SAE 2002-01-3104
Factors Affecting the Friction Coefficients Between Wooden and Plastic Pallets and the Wooden Floor Of A Van-type Semi-trailer

SAE 2002-01-1566
Overview of Carat-4, a Multi-body Simulation and Collision Modeling Program

SAE 2001-01-2755
Factors Affecting the Friction Coefficients Between Wooden Pallets and the Wooden Floor of a Van-type Semi-trailer

SAE 2000-01-3476
Fluid Load Analysis Within the Static Roll Model

RF2000-01
The Post-Kumho Exclusion of a Traffic Accident Reconstruction Expert

SAE 1999-01-3782
A Prototype Computer Based Test System to Test Commercial Vehicle Air Brake Systems: Application and Test Results

SAE 1999-01-3732
Dynamics and Roll Stability of a Loaded Class 8 Tractor-Livestock Semi-Trailer

SAE 973261
Prediction of Steady State Roll Threshold for Loaded Flat Bed Trailers - Theory and Calculation

SAE 971033
Ventilated Brake Rotor Air Flow Investigation

SAE 900106
Skidmark Signatures of ABS-Equipped Passenger Cars

SAE 880066
Combining Scene Data with Trajectory Information for Effective Accident Simulation